Skip to main content

On the Anthropic IPO: Model snark and IPO plumbing

Mitchell Tessier

The Anthropic team at the Nasdaq podium during the opening bell ceremony at MarketSite

So today is undoubtedly a big day for not just Anthropic, but the universe of companies that surround them. I wanted to get some thoughts out about the IPO, because it kind of means a lot for the whole industry in some way.

Prior to co-founding qbash, I worked at Nasdaq, and one of the perks of working at Nasdaq is the chance to attend opening and closing bell ceremonies at MarketSite in New York. I'm naturally a bit of a cynic, and before the first one I attended I'd always thought they were overly manufactured, overly produced and disingenuous. Just this weird CNBC circle jerk, an overly congratulatory thing, for lack of a better term.

You stand there huddled against the curved window, where Times Square pedestrians press their faces up against the glass, behind the cameras and behind the energetic producers dancing across the stage with their clipboards. Adena Friedman, or the head of listings, or some other senior Nasdaq person gives the introduction. The leader of the company that's IPOing says their piece, and then there's this final minute before the bell sounds. It's quite an incredible minute, really, because everything happening in the room, the wall of screens, the lighting, the sound swelling and the cameras directing, is so well produced and choreographed that you get this rush of energy and this crescendo. It goes to ten, then nine, eight, seven, six, five, four, three, two, one, and the room fills with cheers and confetti.

When you're in these ceremonies, it's hard to not get swept up by the emotions, and I imagine the energy in the room today made it one of the most electric ceremonies MarketSite has ever seen. Regardless of your thoughts on Anthropic's business model, their marketing, their sincerity, the quality of their products or the personalities of their leaders, the people in that room have worked incredibly hard and have committed themselves to something. And because it's a small room, they're usually a stand-in for many, many more people who are not in it. You feel the weight of that. You feel the sense of accomplishment, and on an IPO day you feel the joy and overwhelm of people's lives changing. I've seen what those mornings feel like, so congratulations to all of the people who worked really, really hard.

By CNBC's math, the average Anthropic employee is sitting on about $44 million on paper. That's a lot of rich nerds.

You can think what you want about Anthropic, the quality of their models or the character of their leaders. What you should be thinking about is how an IPO like this functions structurally, and why Anthropic might be trying to take advantage of that. You have to separate the celebration from two things. One is how an IPO actually functions. The other is what an IPO of Anthropic's magnitude means, and why they might be doing it now.

How an IPO day actually works

Weeks before anything trades, the investment banks (Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley for Anthropic) take the company on a roadshow and collect orders from their chums at the big funds. That book sets a price. On Wednesday night Anthropic was priced at $83, above its $70 to $78 range. Underwriters allocate those shares at that price to the large institutions, so in effect they're divvying up the pie, making sure everybody gets their nut. Robinhood, SoFi and some other online brokers get a second-tier pittance to peddle to select customers. As I said, I'm a bit of a cynic.

On the day, the exchange runs an opening auction called the IPO Cross, and the stated reason is to "set a fair starting price." Orders build up through the morning. The exchange posts an indicative price and how lopsided the buy and sell orders are, and then the lead underwriter tells the exchange when it's ready to open. You can get an order in through your broker, but brokers can't take a market buy on a new issue before it trades, so you're setting a limit price and hoping. Anthropic opened at $111.50 around noon, 34% above the price the funds paid on Wednesday.

After the open, the banks sell extra shares to "meet retail demand," which also gives them the opportunity to buy back in if the price dips. Most insiders are locked up for around six months. This is where the big IPOs tend to fade. Five of the seven biggest US IPOs, Facebook, Visa, GM, Uber and Rivian, closed their first day below where they opened, and as I'm writing this, Anthropic has slid below $100. The funds that got in at the offer price win, the burden of downside risk lands on retail, and by 2 PM we get calls of pump and dump.

Setting aside whether this is the right system for raising capital, and by right I mean fair and equitable for everyone, Main Street or Wall Street, there are somewhat credible reasons for it, like price discovery, stability and guaranteed capital. Calling it a pump and dump, or saying retail investors are getting purposefully burned, is too simplistic an outlook. This structure of an opening auction, a price set way above the offer, the doors opening to retail and the price dipping as demand gets met is just part of the system now. I don't think any read based on the first day of an IPO would be cogent.

This big? This soon?

The second thing that's interesting about today is the magnitude of the Anthropic IPO and why they may have needed to push for it so soon. This is a commonly held belief in the skeptic crowd. According to its prospectus, Anthropic has about $900 billion in commitments, nearly all of it compute and infrastructure. About $450 billion of that comes due before the end of 2030, and about $70 billion in the next 12 months alone. Google is owed at least $120 billion, Amazon at least $110 billion, SpaceXAI up to $120 billion and Microsoft close to $50 billion. That's the reserved compute, the underlying infrastructure build-out they have their name attached to, which they actually need to grow.

So they need to sell growth before they can grow, and a rushed IPO provides that. They can sell narrative growth to retail investors and normies, and suck up juice from the indexes they'll now be included in. Nasdaq changed the rules on that before the SpaceX IPO. Under a fast-entry rule that took effect in May, a mega listing can join the Nasdaq-100 within weeks instead of waiting months, and Anthropic is on track to join it. People took the same issue with SpaceX. These mega, multi-trillion-dollar IPOs create outsized risk for retail investors through their positions in pension funds and ETFs.

And the growth story has to be sold hard because the moat is thin. As someone put it to me today, everyone says betting on the chip companies is like betting on Cisco in the 90s, but betting on the model companies is the real Cisco bet. Ask what the utility is, and who benefits and drives the cash flow. Outside of highly specialized cases, there's close to zero moat in the models themselves, which is why they're all racing to attack the UX layer.

Why this matters to everyone

Why does this matter to the entire universe of companies around Anthropic?

One, this is obviously precedent-setting for OpenAI, which is reportedly aiming for a 2027 IPO. The hurdle they'll be measured against (and will probably measure themselves against) is the Anthropic IPO. So if you think there's risk in either of the buckets we talked about, IPO day structure favoring institutional finance and mega IPOs leaning on indexes to sell growth rather than grow, you should anticipate more risk in those buckets in 2027.

Two, everything is just so interconnected right now. The stock market doesn't make sense anymore, and the ecosystem surrounding companies like Anthropic is extremely connected and very tenuous. Where Anthropic goes, we all kind of go. What they decide to do, and how they succeed or fail, ripples out to everyone else. We're about to see whether we still have an industry or whether it gets torpedoed financially for the next six months.

So regardless of your thoughts and opinions on the company or their founders, everybody wants this to go at least fine, because it gives us all a bit of runway to keep looking forward.

P.S. I do wonder how much the release of GTA 6 impacts the Anthropic IPO. Only time will tell.

Mitch

Written Thursday, November 19, around 2 PM ET.

Stay in the loop

Product updates, tutorials, and AI insights. No spam.